Photo Credit: FILE PHOTO.
Photo Caption: Alderman Joshua Lusher..
Questions Raised Over Alderman’s Eligibility
By Robert Fang
Published: February 1, 2026
Questions continue to mount regarding whether Ward 1 Alderman Joshua Lusher is legally eligible to serve on the Delavan City Council, following renewed attention to a decades‑old felony conviction and the restrictions imposed under Illinois law.
The issue first came to light after the Delavan Dispatch received a tip raising concerns about Lusher’s eligibility. The Dispatch then conducted an independent review of public records and relevant state statutes, which confirmed the underlying conviction and the legal framework governing municipal officeholders.
Public records from McLean County show that in 1998, at age 21, Lusher was charged with deceptive practices related to a bad check. In June 1999, he entered a guilty plea to a Class 4 felony — the lowest felony classification under Illinois law. While deceptive‑practices cases are often charged or negotiated down to a Class A misdemeanor, the conviction in Lusher’s case remained a felony. The offense occurred 28 years ago.
Under current Illinois statutes, individuals convicted of a felony are disqualified from holding municipal office unless their rights have been restored through specific legal mechanisms, such as a gubernatorial pardon or a Certificate of Restoration of Rights. Although legislation has been proposed in recent years to remove or narrow this prohibition, no such changes have been enacted. The restriction remained in full effect in November 2022, when Lusher filed his statement of candidacy for the Ward 1 seat.
Lusher did not run unopposed in the April 2023 consolidated election. He faced challenger James Horath and won the contest with 55 votes to Horath’s 23.
After questions about his eligibility surfaced, Lusher told the Dispatch he was aware of the conviction but believed at the time that the charge would be reduced to a misdemeanor once he completed the conditions of his plea.
“I am angry with myself,” Lusher said. “I would have never run if I knew this was a problem.”
Lusher said he immediately reached out to his constituents to explain the situation and seek their guidance. He also contacted the mayor and every member of the city council to apprise them of the issue — first offering to resign, and then asking for time to determine whether any legal avenue existed to remove the disqualification.
“I was ready to resign,” he said. “But my constituents wanted me to fight. I feel I owe them that, so I am going to fight.”
The matter appeared on the agenda of the January 20 city council meeting under two items: discussion and possible action on a resignation, and the selection of a new mayor pro tem — a role Lusher currently held. During that meeting, the council unanimously selected Alderman Linda Slabaugh to serve as mayor pro tem.
Public attendance at the meeting drew a notable turnout from Ward 1 residents. Among them was constituent Steve Watts, who spoke in support of allowing Lusher to remain on the council. Watts urged the council to keep the seat vacant, if necessary, to give Lusher time to resolve the eligibility issue.
At that meeting, the council tabled action until a special meeting scheduled for January 27. That meeting was later cancelled to allow additional time for the city to investigate its options.
The next opportunity for the council to take up the matter will be at its regular meeting on February 3.
FILE PHOTO
Alderman Joshua Lusher.
Questions Raised Over Alderman’s Eligibility
Questions continue to mount regarding whether Ward 1 Alderman Joshua Lusher is legally eligible to serve on the Delavan City Council, following renewed attention to a decades‑old felony conviction and the restrictions imposed under Illinois law.