Garbage Proposal Advances
DELAVAN — The Delavan City Council has taken the next step in exploring a citywide garbage collection program by approving a measure that will allow residents to weigh in on the proposal through a mailed survey before any final decision is made.
The council voted to advance the proposal during its recent meeting, authorizing city staff to distribute a survey to all Delavan residents seeking public input on whether the city should consolidate residential garbage collection into its existing utility billing system alongside water and sewer services. The proposal is not yet approved for implementation, but rather moves the discussion into a public feedback phase.
The action follows months of review by city officials after the city issued a Request for Proposals (RFP) seeking bids from waste collection companies interested in providing citywide service.
The city received proposals from four firms: GFL Environmental, Waste Management, Republic Services and Dawdy Dumpster Services.
To assist in evaluating the bids, the council retained consultant Joe Hitchcock of Crystal Creek Advisory Group. Hitchcock reviewed the submissions and assigned scores based on criteria established by the city. Following that assessment, city staff reviewed the consultant’s findings and prepared a recommendation for the council.
City staff ultimately recommended that residents be asked to consider a proposal submitted by GFL Environmental.
Under the GFL proposal, residential garbage collection rates would be locked in for five years, ensuring that the monthly service cost would remain unchanged throughout the contract term. The program would include weekly residential garbage collection with a 95-gallon cart provided to participating households.
Additional services included in the proposal are two annual bulk curbside collection events, eight curbside yard waste collection dates each year and one annual electronics recycling event at a centralized collection location. Electronics would not be picked up curbside.
Recycling service would continue through the existing drop-off site at 607 Chestnut Street.
Residents would have the ability to opt out of the citywide collection program. However, those choosing not to participate would be responsible for managing the removal of their household waste on their own. Residents would not be permitted to contract with another garbage hauling company under the proposed system.
If implemented, garbage collection charges would be added to the city’s monthly utility bill, which currently includes water and sewer services. Utility customers would receive a combined water, sewer and garbage bill.
One of the most discussed aspects of the proposal involves enforcement of unpaid bills. Under the plan, failure to pay any portion of the utility bill, including garbage service charges, could result in water service disconnection.
The proposed monthly cost to residents would be $23.
Of that amount, $18.79 would cover GFL’s collection and disposal services. An additional $0.84 per month would fund Crystal Creek Advisory Group’s contract management services for the first three years of the agreement. The city would receive $3.37 per month to cover administrative expenses, including billing, customer inquiries, electronic payment services and enforcement costs associated with non-payment.
After the consultant management fee expires at the end of three years, the city’s administrative fee would increase to $4.21 per month, keeping the total monthly charge at $23.
The council’s vote was not unanimous.
Alderwoman Becky Lowry was absent from the meeting. All remaining council members voted in favor of advancing the proposal except Alderman Joe Watts, who cast the lone dissenting vote.
Watts emphasized that the vote was solely about moving forward with the survey process and not approving a garbage collection contract. However, he said he opposed advancing the proposal because he believes residents have already expressed their preference to retain private choice in garbage service.
“I voted no to moving forward on the proposed garbage service,” Watts said. “This step of the process was just to send out surveys now that we have bids. I have taken a strong stance against contracting a garbage service because the residents of Delavan already said no to this once.”
“The residents of Delavan have previously made it clear they want to retain the freedom to choose their own garbage service provider,” Watts said. “As elected officials, our responsibility is to represent the residents, not dictate which private businesses they must use.”
City officials stressed that no final decision has been made and that the mailed survey is intended to gauge community sentiment before the council considers whether to adopt the program.